Does the Telemarketing Sales Rule apply to insurance? TSR vs TCPA duties for final expense agencies and their vendors
The FTC’s test for insurance telemarketing, the TSR and TCPA duties of agencies, setter desks, transfer vendors and lead generators, and the call records a transfer vendor and the agency that buys from it keep.
General information, not legal advice. This guide summarizes the rules in the sources listed at the end, as read on . Rules change, and they differ by state and by business, so check with a lawyer licensed where you call before relying on it.
On this page
- Does the Telemarketing Sales Rule apply to final expense telemarketing?
- How do the TSR and the TCPA differ for an insurance agency?
- Which TSR and TCPA duties fall on the agency, the setter desk, the transfer vendor and the lead generator?
- If the TSR applies, which call records must a transfer operation keep for five years, and how do you ask for them?
- Why did the FTC act against an insurance lead generator anyway?
- What did the 2024 TSR amendments change?
- Questions
- Sources
The Telemarketing Sales Rule applies to final expense telemarketing unless the activity is the business of insurance regulated by state law and, the FTC’s current guide adds, enforcing the TSR would conflict with that law. The test looks at the activity and the states, not who dials. The FCC’s rules have no insurance exception in their text.
This guide is for final expense agencies and their call floors that buy leads or transfers, or hire setters; calling hours, penalties and consent wording have separate guides. Rules as published on October 22, 2026. This is not legal advice.
Does the Telemarketing Sales Rule apply to final expense telemarketing?
The Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR, 16 CFR Part 310) is the FTC’s rule against deceptive and abusive telemarketing, written under the Telemarketing Act (15 U.S.C. 6102(a)(1)). It reaches only what the FTC Act reaches: “no activity which is outside the jurisdiction of that Act shall be affected by this chapter” (15 U.S.C. 6105(a)). The McCarran-Ferguson Act applies the FTC Act to the business of insurance only “to the extent that such business is not regulated by State Law” (15 U.S.C. 1012(b)). So the answer turns on what the activity is, and whether and how state law regulates it.
The Commission’s test: the business of insurance, regulated by state law
The FTC set out the test in Advisory Opinion 03-1, issued by direction of the Commission on August 19, 2003, to counsel for Stonebridge Life Insurance Company:
“The McCarran-Ferguson Act does not exempt insurance companies from the FTC’s jurisdiction, but rather exempts only those activities that constitute ‘the business of insurance,’ regardless of who performs them, and then only to the extent that such activities are regulated by state law.”
- Is the activity the business of insurance? The opinion sets out the three questions from the Supreme Court’s 1982 Pireno decision: “First, does the activity have the effect of transferring or spreading a policyholder’s risk; second, is the activity an integral part of the policy relationship between the insurer and the insured; and third, is the practice limited to entities within the insurance industry.”
- Is it regulated by state law? The opinion also asks “whether the state regulation was enacted for the purpose of regulating the ‘business of insurance.’” Where an interstate sale is involved, it asks whether the practice is regulated “by the states in which the practice has its impact” and whether those states can exert local control “through [their] own provisions, instrumentalities, and processes.”
The Commission “may assert jurisdiction over the telemarketing of insurance products only if the telemarketing activity fails the Pireno test and/or fails the state regulation test.” It made no ruling on Stonebridge’s calls, saying it “would need additional information, including, but not limited to, the nature of the product offered, the state(s) in which it is sold, and the extent of state regulation in those states.”
The FTC’s current business guide words the exemption more narrowly. Coverage “depends on the extent to which state law regulates insurance telemarketing,” it says, and “If state law regulates the telemarketing at issue and enforcement of the TSR would conflict with and effectively supersede those statelaws [sic], then the TSR would not apply.” The 2003 opinion states no such conflict condition.
Why hiring a call center does not settle the question
Banks, common carriers and nonprofits sit outside FTC jurisdiction, but the FTC’s guide says companies that contract to telemarket for them “must comply with the TSR.” Insurance is treated differently: hiring a third-party caller does not by itself bring the TSR in. The guide says “the TSR does not necessarily apply simply because the campaign is conducted by a third-party telemarketer,” and the 2003 opinion adds, “Whether the telemarketing is done by third-party call centers or by an insurance company is not determinative.” Neither line says the TSR never applies. The third Pireno question, whether the practice is limited to entities within the insurance industry, is the open one for a lead generator or transfer vendor that is not itself an insurer or agency; no source we read answers it for final expense calls.
What the Telemarketing Sales Rule’s text says about insurance
Nothing: the word does not appear in Part 310 (eCFR text current to October 19, 2026). The FTC chose not to add an exemption. Commenting on the FTC’s 2002 proposal, the National Association of Insurance & Financial Advisors asked for “an explicit statement of exemption in the Rule”; in the January 2003 final rule the FTC declined because “its jurisdictional limitations regarding the business of insurance are clear, and thus no express exemption for these entities is necessary” (68 FR 4580, 4587). The rule also covers only a campaign that “involves more than one interstate telephone call” (310.2(ii)). State telemarketing statutes are a separate layer from state insurance regulation; see how state telemarketing laws treat licensed insurance agents.
The FCC’s side has no such test in its text: neither 47 U.S.C. 227 nor 47 CFR 64.1200 uses the word “insurance,” so plan on the consent and calling rules that stay with a transfer buyer whatever the TSR answer. Whether McCarran-Ferguson could ever displace a TCPA rule is a question for counsel. Carriers can also require TSR compliance: Guarantee Trust Life’s telemarketing rules, as posted by Pinnacle Financial Services on September 20, 2024, warn that failing to follow the TSR and the TCPA “may jeopardize your appointment with GTL.”
How do the TSR and the TCPA differ for an insurance agency?
The TSR reaches insurance only as far as the FTC Act does, needs interstate calls, treats whoever initiates or receives the calls as a telemarketer, and lists eleven categories of records. The FCC’s rules have no insurance exception or interstate element in their text, define the telemarketer as the party that initiates a call, and list no per-call record.
In the next two tables, bare paragraph letters such as (d)(3) refer to 47 CFR 64.1200; TSR cites start with 310.
| Point | Telemarketing Sales Rule (16 CFR 310) | FCC rules under the TCPA (47 CFR 64.1200) |
|---|---|---|
| Who writes it | The FTC, under the Telemarketing Act (15 U.S.C. 6102(a)(1)) | The FCC, under the TCPA (47 U.S.C. 227(b)(2), (c)(2)) |
| Reach into insurance | Only as far as the FTC Act reaches (15 U.S.C. 1012(b), 6105(a)) | No insurance exception in the text of 47 U.S.C. 227 or 64.1200 |
| What counts as telemarketing | A campaign that “involves more than one interstate telephone call” (310.2(ii)) | “the initiation of a telephone call or message” to encourage a purchase ((f)(13)), with no interstate element |
| Roles | Seller (310.2(ee)); telemarketer: anyone who “initiates or receives” the calls (310.2(hh)) | Seller: the person or entity “on whose behalf a telephone call or message is initiated” ((f)(10)); telemarketer: the one that “initiates” it ((f)(12)) |
| Records the rule lists | Eleven categories, kept five years (310.5) | The do-not-call list and each request ((d)(3), (d)(6)); records documenting the registry scrub process, a safe-harbor condition ((c)(2)(i)(D)); records showing compliance with the (a)(7) limit on abandoned calls ((a)(7)(iii)); no per-call record |
| Calls to businesses | Exempt, except that since May 16, 2024 the bans on material misrepresentations and false or misleading statements apply, among other limits (310.6(b)(7)) | Do-not-call rules protect residential subscribers ((c), (d)); (e) applies them to wireless numbers “to the extent described in” FCC 03-153, which presumes a registered wireless subscriber is residential |
| Established business relationship | 540 days after a purchase, 90 after an inquiry (310.2(q)) | 18 months and 3 months ((f)(5)); the DNC scrubbing guide has the full comparison |
For transfer buyers the roles row matters most: an agency floor that only takes transfers can fit the TSR’s telemarketer definition, but not the FCC’s. TSR and TCPA penalties are in the fines guide. For a lead a call center passes on rather than a live call, see the calling duties that stay with a lead buyer.
Which TSR and TCPA duties fall on the agency, the setter desk, the transfer vendor and the lead generator?
The agency is the seller under both rules and answers for unhonored do-not-call requests. Setter desks and transfer vendors are telemarketers with their own logging and record duties. A lead generator is a telemarketer when it calls, and otherwise faces the TSR for knowingly assisting a violation or misusing a do-not-call list. TSR duties apply only where the campaign fails the activity test above.
| Party | TSR status and FCC role | Scrubbing and registry access | Stop-request log | Call-detail records (TSR) | Consent records |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agency | Seller under both rules (310.2(ee); (f)(10)); taking transfers, it also “receives” calls (310.2(hh)) | Must have registry access to each area code, paid where a fee applies, before it or a telemarketer calls there, unless it calls only people with a written agreement or business relationship and uses the registry for nothing else (310.8(a), (c)); FCC safe harbor: its own purchased access ((c)(2)(i)(E)) | Liable when another party keeps its list and fails to honor do-not-call requests ((d)(3)) | Keeps them unless a written allocation shifts them, then polices the vendor and keeps access (310.5(e)) | Keeps them unless allocated in writing (310.5(a)(8)) |
| Setter desk | Telemarketer under both rules (310.2(hh); (f)(12)), calling on the agency’s behalf; names the caller and the agency on each call ((d)(4)) | Uses the agency’s account number at no cost after confirming the agency paid; never splits one subscription across clients (FTC guide; 310.8(b), (c)) | Records each request when made ((d)(3)); the TSR log names the telemarketer (310.5(a)(10)) | Keeps them unless allocated; hand-dialed single numbers drop items (vii) and (x) | As allocated in writing |
| Transfer vendor | Telemarketer under both rules; which seller its screener names before a buyer is chosen is open (310.4(d)(1); (d)(4)) | Names each seller it accesses the registry for, with that seller’s account number (310.8(e)) | Records requests when made; whose list a request joins on a multi-buyer call is open | Includes the transfer record unless screeners dial by hand; plus its service providers (310.5(a)(9)) | For any consent its calls rely on (310.5(a)(8)) |
| Lead generator | A telemarketer when it places calls (310.2(hh); (f)(12)), as the FTC alleged against MediaAlpha (complaint ¶102); otherwise liable for substantial assistance given while it “knows or consciously avoids knowing” of a violation (310.3(b)) | May use do-not-call lists only for compliance (310.4(b)(2)) | Keeps one as a telemarketer when it calls | As a telemarketer when it calls | No 310.5 duty unless it is a seller or telemarketer; the consent text it sells is the buyer’s evidence |
The agency: the seller the calls are made for
The TSR’s seller also “arranges for others to provide goods or services” (310.2(ee)), and the rule makes it a violation “for a seller to cause a telemarketer to engage in” the conduct 310.4(b)(1) bans, do-not-call violations included. The FTC’s guide: “Ultimately, a seller is responsible for keeping a current entity-specific Do Not Call list, either through a telemarketing service it hires or its own efforts.” Ask any vendor that captures consent for you to show the consent record it would produce; for comparison, our compliance page sets out how our campaign builds capture and keep consent records.
Setter desks and transfer vendors: telemarketers with their own duties
Two services put a telemarketer between you and the consumer: a setter desk, where you hire callers who follow up the leads you already have, and an interest-verified transfer (“A screener confirms the prospect’s interest, age and state, then warm-transfers the call to you.”). Neither moves a duty off the agency: the telemarketer’s duties sit beside the seller’s. Each must identify the caller and the business the call is made for, with a number or address to reach it (64.1200(d)(4)), and record a do-not-call request “at the time the request is made” (64.1200(d)(3)). See who answers for the calls a setter desk makes and who scrubs against which list, and how often.
Transfer vendors add two questions no rule text answers directly: which seller a screener names before a buyer is chosen, and whose list a “don’t call me” said before the handoff joins. The nearest text, the last sentence of 64.1200(d)(3), needs the consumer’s “prior express permission” to pass a do-not-call request beyond the business the call is made for and its affiliates. Get the vendor’s answers in writing and put both to counsel.
Lead generators: liability for substantial assistance
A lead generator that only collects and sells data is reached through 310.3(b): it is a violation “for a person to provide substantial assistance or support to any seller or telemarketer when that person knows or consciously avoids knowing” of a violation. The FTC’s guide calls deliberate ignorance “an ineffective strategy to avoid liability” and lists suppliers of “mailing lists, automated dialing software, or telephony services” among its examples. Once a lead generator dials consumers itself, it fits the telemarketer definition (310.2(hh)), and the FTC’s complaint against MediaAlpha, below, alleged exactly that.
If the TSR applies, which call records must a transfer operation keep for five years, and how do you ask for them?
Telemarketing Sales Rule record retention runs five years “from the date the record is produced unless specified otherwise” (16 CFR 310.5(a)), matching the five-year “statute of limitations for the FTC to seek civil penalties under the TSR” (89 FR 26760). The FTC wanted call records because they are “necessary for the Commission to determine whether the TSR applies.”
The records list, item by item
Nine of the rule’s eleven categories follow; the other two cover prize recipients ((a)(3)), which matter only if a campaign promises prizes, and previous charity donors ((a)(6)).
- Marketing material: each substantially different ad, script and promotional piece, and each unique prerecorded message, kept five years after last use ((a)(1)).
- A call-detail record per call ((a)(2)): telemarketer, seller, product, consumer or business, outbound or not, prerecorded or not, calling and called numbers, date, time, duration, the script and any prerecorded message used, the caller ID shown with proof of the right to use it, and the disposition, such as answered, connected, dropped or transferred. Times run to the second, in UTC ((b)(3)–(4)).
- The transfer record: “the telephone number or IP address that the call was transferred to as well as the company name, if the call was transferred to a company different from the seller or telemarketer that placed the call” ((a)(2)(x)).
- Customers and inquiries: each sale (buyer, contact details, product, dates, amount paid) and each inquiry behind a claimed business relationship ((a)(4)–(5)).
- Staff in phone sales, with each fictitious name “traceable to only one specific employee” ((a)(7)).
- Consent: who consented and at what number, the request as it was shown, the purpose, a copy of the consent and its date ((a)(8)). For consent to call a registered number or to receive prerecorded messages, among others, the record must also show everything that rule requires, the signature and the authorized party included ((a)(8)(vi)).
- Service providers used to deliver outbound calls, with contracts kept five years after they expire ((a)(9)).
- The stop-request log: name, numbers, seller, “the telemarketer that called the person,” date and product ((a)(10)).
- The registry-version record: who accessed the registry, when, under which account number and for which campaign ((a)(11)).
A missing or inaccurate record “is a violation of this part” ((c)). For call-detail records only, documented procedures, training and monitoring excuse a temporary, inadvertent gap “corrected within 30 days of discovery” ((d)).
When a screener dials by hand
For “calls that an individual telemarketer makes by manually entering a single telephone number to initiate the call to that number,” a seller or telemarketer “need not retain the records specified in paragraphs (a)(2)(vii) and (a)(2)(x)”: the numbers, date, time and duration, and the disposition that holds the transfer record. The rest of the call-detail record still applies. So ask how a vendor dials before you ask for transfer records: a screener keying one number at a time may properly have none, while a vendor whose dialer places the calls should have one per transfer. Whether click-to-dial or preview dialing counts as manual entry is a question for counsel.
How to ask a transfer vendor for the records
- A written allocation of every 310.5 record, with your access to any record kept for you; without a clear one, “both the telemarketer and the seller are responsible” (310.5(e)).
- How screeners dial: any dialer, or one number keyed by hand at a time.
- One sample call-detail record filled with test data, showing the transfer number or IP address and company name.
- The consent request as the consumer saw it, kept “in the same manner and format in which it was presented” (310.5(a)(8)(ii)), to check whose name the consent carries.
- The service-provider list and the registry-version record for your campaign, and whose account number was used.
- The fields of its stop-request log.
- Who holds the records if it closes or is sold: the principal of a dissolved business, or the successor after a sale (310.5(f)).
Delivery fields, certificates and replacement terms are in the full list of record and delivery details to request from any vendor.
Why did the FTC act against an insurance lead generator anyway?
The filings show what the FTC charged: a lead generator’s harvesting and resale of consumer data, its robocalls and its sale of live calls (MediaAlpha), and sales calls by companies named as insurance agencies (Top Healthcare Options). Neither complaint mentions McCarran-Ferguson or final expense, so the filings do not say how the Act was weighed.
What the MediaAlpha complaint charged under the TSR
The FTC sued MediaAlpha, Inc. and QuoteLab, LLC in the Central District of California on August 6, 2025 (No. 2:25-cv-07263). The complaint describes consumers “interested in health plans and other insurance products.” It alleges that the companies took consumers’ personal and contact information and “auction it off to telemarketers and other lead generators,” and that they robocall consumers and “sell access to the ‘live’ call to their telemarketer partners.” Paragraph 102 states the theory: “Defendants are telemarketers engaging in telemarketing when initiating telephone calls to consumers. Defendants through their lead generation activities provide substantial assistance or support to sellers and telemarketers.” Three TSR counts follow: “Initiation of Calls to Numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry” (Count VI), “Initiation of Unlawful Prerecorded Messages” (Count VII) and “Assisting and Facilitating Violations of the TSR” (Count VIII).
What the order asks of the companies that buy its leads
The court entered the stipulated order on October 16, 2025 (ECF No. 17); the companies “neither admit nor deny” the complaint’s allegations except as the order states. Section VI bars them, “in connection with Telemarketing,” from “violating the TSR.” Section V, written for “Healthcare-Related Products,” makes the companies do the following with each buyer, which the order calls a demand partner:
- get a signed acknowledgement “expressly agreeing to comply with Sections I and VI of this Order,” or stop doing business with it until it signs;
- review a “random sample of all telephonic communications covering at least a 30-day period” within 60 days after a buyer starts and at least yearly, and review its sales scripts and the complaints they receive about it (carriers, their affiliates and captive brokers that certify they sell one carrier’s health plans, with that carrier monitoring the calls or approving the scripts, are excused from the recording and script reviews);
- carry out “due diligence at least annually regarding any law enforcement actions or Telemarketing-related legal proceedings” against it.
The order does not name final expense, but it shows what a lead generator under an FTC order can ask of its buyers: a signed TSR promise, call recordings and scripts. The fines guide sets its dollars beside a 2023 order against another lead generator, Fluent: see what the MediaAlpha and Fluent orders cost.
A 2026 case against insurance agencies that took transferred calls
On January 12, 2026 the FTC filed a sealed complaint in the Southern District of Florida (No. 0:26-cv-60067) against Top Healthcare Options Insurance Agency Inc and 11 related defendants, four of the 12 with “Insurance Agency” in their names, and announced it on January 23 after the court entered a temporary restraining order and the seal was lifted. The defendants acquired leads from lead generators: “Defendants then call consumers, either directly or through the lead generators, who transfer the calls to Defendants” (¶33). The complaint calls them “seller[s]” or “telemarketer[s]” under 310.2(ee), (hh) and (ii) (¶66) and brings TSR counts for misrepresentations (Count II) and failure to disclose material information (Count III). The products were limited benefit plans and medical discount memberships, which the FTC’s release says “are not comprehensive health insurance or equivalent to such plans.”
What did the 2024 TSR amendments change?
Three final rules amended the TSR in 2024. Two reach a final expense agency: the April rule on records and calls to businesses, and the August update to registry-access fees, whose amounts are in the DNC scrubbing guide. The December rule concerns technical-support calls.
| Date | Document | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| April 16, 2024 | 89 FR 26760 (FR Doc. 2024-07180) | Final rule published |
| May 16, 2024 | 89 FR 26760 | In effect: records kept five years instead of two; new records for each call, inquiry-based business relationships, service providers, do-not-call requests and the registry version; consent records spelled out; calls to businesses brought under the bans on material misrepresentations and false or misleading statements |
| August 29, 2024 | 89 FR 70095 (FR Doc. 2024-19431) | Registry-access fee update to 310.8(c) and (d), effective October 1, 2024; later fee rules have replaced its amounts |
| October 15, 2024 | 89 FR 26760 | Compliance date for 310.5(a)(2), the call-detail record that holds the transfer record |
| December 10, 2024 | 89 FR 99069 (FR Doc. 2024-28399) | Final rule extending the TSR to inbound calls that answer technical-support ads |
| January 9, 2025 | 89 FR 99069 | In effect; it concerns technical-support calls, and it re-lettered the 310.2 definitions, moving the telemarketer definition from (gg) to (hh) |
Call-detail records, the transfer record included, were not required for calls before October 15, 2024, so a vendor’s records may start on that date. The FTC’s business guide has not caught up: it still says records are kept “for two years” and that “Most phone calls between a telemarketer and a business are exempt from the TSR,” so cite the rule text.